|
News Clips
Health Affairs (7/16) Making Value-Based Payment the Best Choice for Providers – Providers will only make a decisive pivot toward value and health generation if the business case for value-based payment (VBP) is compelling and other paths to sustainable revenues are closed off. CMMI can catalyze such a pivot by deploying its resources and legal flexibilities to broaden VBP participation and diminish arbitrage opportunities. Doing so will require political courage. At this juncture, continuing to curate models or layering new technologies and patient engagement strategies over the same models will only yield marginal gains. CMMI should instead consider investing in mandatory models to drive organizational focus on VBP and foundational research and development of alternative fee schedules and risk-adjustment methodologies. These are activities that CMMI has unique legal authority and resources to undertake.
National Bureau of Economic Research (7/16) Are Hospital Acquisitions of Physician Practices Anticompetitive? – This paper empirically analyzes the effects of mergers between complementary firms on competition and pricing. As these non-horizontal mergers have become more common, there is increasing interest in evaluating both potential efficiencies such as eliminating double marginalization and potential anticompetitive effects such as foreclosure and recapture. Hospital acquisitions of physician practices have reshaped the $1 trillion US physician industry, nearly doubling the share of physicians working for hospitals between 2008 and 2016. Focusing on childbirths, the most ubiquitous admission among the privately insured, these mergers led to price increases for hospitals and physicians of 3.3 percent and 15.1 percent, respectively, with no discernible effects on quality measures. Our estimates suggest that the costs of these mergers of hospitals and physicians have been substantial, and our mechanism tests offer guidance in predicting where the anticompetitive effects of non-horizontal mergers are likely to be strongest.
Healthcare Innovation (7/21) Expert: Corporatization Is Already Harming U.S. Healthcare – Confronting corporatization may require a fundamental reorientation of the industrial organization of the health system. Additional reforms could entail structurally separating (“breaking up”) conglomerates that sit on both sides of the payer–provider bargaining dyad by barring insurers from owning physician practices or PBMs from owning pharmacies, standardizing prices to limit monopoly power and financial preferencing of an organization’s related entities over competitors, expanding alternative sources of capital, and modernizing corporate-practice-of-medicine laws. Furthermore, rules for governance and ownership of health care entities might be revisited to require, for example, higher standards for nonprofit tax exemption, clinical and community representation on governing boards, fiduciary duties beyond shareholder primacy, or increased parent-company or investor liability for operational choices that harm patients or the community’s access to care.
Health Affairs (7/22) Revisiting Geographic Direct Contracting: A Blueprint for a Better Version – Health policy experts speculate that the 2021 Geographic Direct Contracting (Geo) Model will be one of the potential revivals of previously shelved Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI) models during the second Trump administration. The Biden administration suspended the Geo model before implementation began, but with CMMI’s focus on rising health care costs and Medicare’s increasing fiscal challenges the model may be an opportunity to create the reforms this administration wants. The authors provide recommendations for how CMMI could improve a revitalized Geo model including leveraging Medicare’s administrative efficiency, simplifying financial mechanisms, implementing a gradual and predictable discount structure, simplifying alignment methodology, and building on existing ACO infrastructure. This paper also highlights elements of the original Geo model that CMMI should preserve including regional accountability, flexible provider arrangements, and outcomes-based quality measurement.
|