#31 - 6 June 2020

Housing: everything must change so that nothing changes

Will the unprecedented experience of lockdown and its direct consequence, the economic and social crisis, transform the housing sector? In Paris, a city with a very tense real estate market, will the crisis linked to the Covid-19 epidemic finally burst what is sometimes referred to as a "real estate bubble"? Will the predicted exodus of urban dwellers towards greener pastures, motivated by the negative aspects of metropolitan life and the appeal of teleworking, become a reality? Will the fear of the coronavirus lead to a definitive disaffection of dense housing? What kind of habitat will we dream of after having lived confined, for some, in dark or poorly insulated, cramped and sometimes over-occupied housing for almost two months?

It is tempting to project one's hopes and fears onto the widely commented "world after the crisis". However, it is clear that the coming world is very similar to its predecessor. The likelihood of a significant drop in property prices in the most expensive cities, to say nothing of a crash, remains almost non-existent: in Paris, there are no fewer than 90 buyers for every seller, compared with 10 nationwide! The risk of a significant decrease in demand, under the combined effect of the expected fall in purchasing power and increased difficulties in accessing credit, remains very limited in Paris and other high-priced cities, where demand comes from high-income households, which are less vulnerable to economic uncertainties. In any event, even a significant decrease in demand would not alter the balance of forces in this market, which is very favorable to sellers.

What about the influx of disappointed urban dwellers towards greener horizons? Will this be an epiphenomenon, destined to remain for most of them in a state of aspiration (23% of French people and 38% of Parisians wanted to move as a result of confinement, according to Forum Vies Mobiles) or a fundamental trend? Difficult to say. The coming economic turmoil will certainly lead some companies to encourage teleworking in order to reduce their real estate expenses. At the same time, the demand for housing could increase in peri-urban areas, which offer households the possibility of combining individual housing with proximity to metropolitan amenities. Medium-sized cities could also do well, as André Yché, Chairman of the Management Board of CDC Habitat, recently predicted in the JDD: "When the crisis is over, many city dwellers could (...) acquire (...) a residence with a garden, in the countryside or in a small town two or two and a half hours from the metropolis. It would only take 2 or 3% of the active categories to opt for this choice in order to tip the market in the heart of the city. This would imply an adaptation of the new programs in favor of a rental offer of small pied-à-terre, near railway stations but also in favor of small peripheral towns". André Yché sees this as "an unhoped-for opportunity to revitalize medium-sized towns, particularly those known as cathedrals around Paris (Chartres, Evreux, Rouen, Reims, Troyes, etc.)". However, the central cities of the major metropolises will undoubtedly remain extremely attractive, partly because potential buyers, high-income households, will, once again, be largely spared by the economic crisis; while the unemployment rate is expected to reach 10% this year, job seekers will seek to move even closer to these areas, which concentrate economic opportunities and job offers, which means that they will try to find housing, when they can, in these very areas, but much more often in the outskirts, where housing prices are lower, even if it means accepting longer commuting trips. In any case, metropolises will not lose their attractiveness, and the idea of an exodus from large cities to small towns, medium-sized towns and the countryside should be tempered.

For this reason, it seems illusory to anticipate any disaffection for the dense housing that is characteristic of the hearts of large cities: necessity is the law, and aspirations for a "green" life will come up against the harsh reality of an ailing job market for a large number of households. It is therefore urgent to start thinking now about how to consolidate the supply of affordable housing in attractive metropolises, at a time when the crisis has revealed the need to free ourselves from the logic of standardization. From now on, it will be necessary to design housing that is affordable, pleasant to live in and adapted to the environment in which it is located and to the changing expectations of its occupants. No small feat! – Marie Baléo, Head of Studies and Publications


No time to read? La Fabrique de la Cité has got you covered.

“SUPER CITIES” The Upper House of the Japanese Diet passed a law on May 27th authorizing the building of “super cities. Their purpose is to solve social challenges such as depopulation and ageing, using technologies like artificial intelligence, autonomous vehicles, contactless payment, telemedicine... Their creation echoes the prototype of “city of the future” announced by Toyota in January. – Sarah Cosatto, Research Officer

→ Find out more about our work on smart cities.

In China, air pollution is back to its pre-COVID-19 levels. This is primarily due to the fact that polluting industries recovered rapidly, including coal plants. Europe will likely face a similar rebound effect, though its extent remains unknown. – Camille Combe, Project Manager

“TO TRAVEL IS TO LIVE” – This Hans Christian Andersen quote may be taking on a bitter tone for the tourism industry. Trips booked well in advance or at the last second, relaxed cancellation conditions, green tourism rather than metropolitan tourism, transformation of the hotel and restaurant industry: what business model for the post-COVID-19 tourism industry? – Chloë Voisin-Bormuth, Director of Studies and Research

– While activities cautiously resume in cities, the New York subway reopening plan is causing confrontations between the MTA and the mayor. Bill de Blasio has urged the MTA to limit train and bus capacity – a proposal described as “unworkable” by an MTA spokesperson. How can these positions be reconciled to prevent a modal shift from public transport to cars ? – Sarah Cosatto

→ Read our issue brief tackling telecommuting and its effects on mobilities.

HOUSING, QUARANTINE, AND SINGLE PARENTING – The health crisis and confinement have revealed inequalities in housing conditions. However, these inequalities did not appear suddenly with the virus. Instead, they are the result of long-term deterioration which dates back, for single-parent households among the most exposed to residential precariousness, to the early 2000s, as Laure Crepin and Fanny Bugeja-Bloch explain in Metropolitics (in French). - Raphaël Languillon-Aussel, Senior Research Officer

Recent publications